Name _________________
Date___________________
English 10
Pro/Con Essay #7 Rubric Sheet
____
Ideas and Development
20 __ clear thesis statement containing your
position on the topic (please under line this)
__ at least two
specific, descriptive examples and commentary explaining your readers’ potential objections to
your position (cons)
__ at least three
specific, descriptive examples and commentary explaining the
best arguments for your position (pros)
__ strategic balance
between the pros and cons
__ choice of examples
on each side was both intelligent and fair
____
Organization
15 __ appropriate,
effective title
__ effective
introduction that makes your topic clear
__ logical sequencing
of paragraphs (cons before pros)
__ cons arranged in
most strategic order ( neutral)
__ pros arranged in
most strategic order (neutral)
__ clear focus and
abundant detail/elaboration in each body paragraph
__ effective
transitions between paragraphs (underline
the transitions)
__ effective
conclusion, use opinion and commentary.
____
Sentence Fluency, Voice, and Word Choice
7 __ sentences flow and
read smoothly
__ variety in sentence
length and structure
__ respectful,
unbiased voice and word choice
__ vivid, descriptive
word choice (highlight five words
that show this)
____
Conventions
8 __ neat and legible
(typed, double-spaced)
__ proper spelling,
punctuation, and usage
__ no fragments,
run-ons, or comma splices
____
Total Score
50
Assignment: Choose a controversial issue that has two
clear sides to it. Write a persuasive
essay in the pro/con format. Present
arguments for both sides in a fair and respectful manner, with special weight
given to the side that you favor (the pro side). Staple this sheet on top of the essay.